Selling or Buying a Business? Don’t Overlook Its Google Business Profile
By Steve Van Leeuwen, Florida Business Opportunities
When owners get ready to sell, they focus on the usual things: financial statements, equipment, employees, customer lists, and profit. All of that matters. But there is one asset sellers tend to forget about and buyers often skip right past: the company’s Google Business Profile, the listing that used to be called Google My Business.
As a Sarasota Business Broker working with owners all over Southwest Florida, I’ve come to see a well-kept Google profile as one of the most underrated assets a small business can have.
Consider how customers shop today. When someone needs an air conditioning company, a commercial cleaner, a lawn service, or an auto repair shop, the first thing they usually do is search Google. What they find there often decides whether they call you or your competitor.
A buyer looking at your business will do the exact same thing.
Sellers: Your Google Profile Is Part of Your Goodwill
In many business sales, a large share of the price is goodwill. That is the value beyond the physical assets: your reputation, your customer relationships, your name recognition, and your ability to keep bringing in new work.
A strong Google profile is visible proof of that goodwill.
Picture two HVAC companies in Sarasota.
Company A has been in business 20 years. It has 275 Google reviews averaging 4.8 stars, current photos of its technicians on the job, and a steady stream of recent reviews praising its service. The owner answers reviews professionally and keeps the listing up to date.
Company B has about the same revenue and earnings, but only 17 reviews, a 3.9 rating, photos from six years ago, and several complaints nobody ever answered.
Which one would you rather own?
The financials still come first. But most buyers I know would lean toward Company A, because it has something that takes years to build: a public track record that keeps the phone ringing.
Reviews Are an Asset You Can’t Buy Overnight
One of the first things I tell buyers to check is the company’s Google reviews. And I don’t mean just the star rating.
Look at how many reviews there are, how often new ones come in, what customers actually say, and how the owner responds. A business with 300 genuine reviews averaging 4.7 stars usually has a stronger reputation than one with 12 reviews at a perfect 5.0.
The dates matter even more. If a company has 200 great reviews but the newest one is two years old, that raises questions. Is it still busy? Has service slipped? Did the owner stop paying attention? There may be a simple explanation, but a careful buyer should ask.
Compare that with a company picking up five to ten new reviews every month. That pattern points to an active, engaged customer base, which is especially important for businesses that live on repeat work and referrals.
My advice to sellers: don’t wait until you decide to sell to start asking happy customers for reviews. Make it part of how you run the business every week. Ask for honest feedback, and never offer incentives or try to game the ratings. Google’s rules prohibit that, and buyers can spot it.
A reputation that built up naturally over several years carries far more weight than a sudden pile of reviews that shows up right before the listing goes live.
Don’t Let Your Profile Look Abandoned
I see this all the time. A company is doing great revenue and treating customers well, but its Google listing looks like nobody has touched it in years. Old photos. Wrong hours. Missing services. An outdated phone number.
Google lets owners post photos, videos, updates, and offers right on the profile. Use them. They show customers, and buyers, that the business is active and professional. A few examples:
- A commercial lawn company can post photos of properties it maintains and recent landscape projects.
- An HVAC company can show its technicians installing commercial equipment.
- A manufacturer can show its machinery, capabilities, and finished products.
- A commercial cleaning company can show the kinds of facilities it services.
- A detailing business can post before-and-after shots.
These updates help customers understand what you do. They also let a buyer get a feel for your operation before ever walking through the door. When two businesses are otherwise similar, the one that looks sharp online has the edge.
Sellers: A Strong Google Presence Can Support Your Price
Buyers aren’t just paying for what a business earned in the past. They are paying for what it will earn after the seller walks away. That means they care about systems, customer relationships, brand recognition, and anything else that gives the company an advantage.
A well-run Google profile is one of those advantages. A home service company with hundreds of strong reviews has a real head start over a new competitor with none, and the new owner doesn’t have to build that reputation from scratch.
There is a catch, though. Great reviews alone don’t automatically justify a higher price. The case is strongest when the seller can show that Google Search and Maps actually produce calls, customers, and revenue.
When I market a business, I would much rather hand a buyer proof that Google brings in good leads than simply tell them the company has a great reputation. Strong reviews, steady activity, and documented lead flow together make the asking price much easier to defend.
Buyers: Put Google on Your Due Diligence List
Buyers spend weeks on tax returns, financial statements, payroll, equipment, and customer concentration. The Google profile deserves some of that attention too. You don’t want to buy a company with great historical numbers and a reputation that is quietly going downhill.
Here are the questions I suggest buyers work through:
1. How many reviews does it have? A solid number of real reviews suggests an established reputation, but judge it against the industry and the size of the company.
2. How recent are they? Steady activity beats a big batch from years ago.
3. Do the same complaints keep coming up? Repeated mentions of sloppy work, missed appointments, billing problems, rude staff, or unreturned calls can point to real operational issues.
4. Does the owner respond to negative reviews? Every business gets a complaint now and then. One unhappy customer doesn’t worry me much. An owner who ignores a clear pattern of fair complaints does. A thoughtful reply shows management cares about fixing problems.
5. Are the photos and details current? Stale photos and wrong information often signal weak marketing and loose attention to detail.
6. Does the business show up when customers search? Search for its services the way a customer would, using local phrases like “commercial lawn maintenance Sarasota” or “air conditioning repair Bradenton.” See how it stacks up against competitors. Keep in mind that local results shift depending on where you search from.
7. Can the seller prove how much business comes from Google? Ask for profile performance data, website analytics, call tracking reports, and lead source records. Wherever possible, tie Google activity to actual revenue.
None of this replaces financial due diligence. But it can turn up problems, and opportunities, that the financial statements won’t show you.
Buyers: Watch for a Sudden Wave of Five-Star Reviews
If a business suddenly racks up dozens of five-star reviews in a short window, take a closer look. It may be perfectly innocent. Maybe the owner just started asking customers for reviews. But a spike right before the business goes up for sale deserves some scrutiny.
Read the reviews themselves. Do customers describe specific jobs and real experiences, or do they sound generic and repetitive?
Don’t assume fraud without evidence. Just don’t treat every five-star rating as proof of great service either. The goal is to find out whether the online reputation matches what customers really experience.
Make Sure the Profile Actually Transfers to the Buyer
This is a detail both sides need to handle before closing.
A Google Business Profile is managed through a Google account, and that account might belong to the owner, an employee, or an outside marketing firm. A surprising number of owners don’t know who holds primary ownership of their own listing.
Imagine buying a company with 400 positive reviews and then finding out the seller can’t hand over the profile because a former employee or an old marketing agency controls it. That is a problem you want solved well before closing day.
Google has a process for transferring primary ownership of an existing profile. When a business changes hands and keeps operating under the same name, the reviews can generally stay with it. Google recommends transferring ownership rather than starting over so the information and reviews are preserved. Major changes to the business, though, can affect whether reviews stay or whether the profile still qualifies.
My recommendation is simple. Put the transfer of the Google Business Profile in the purchase agreement, and confirm the seller actually has the authority to transfer it. Buyers should make sure they will have proper owner access at closing, and both sides should allow for Google’s limits on what newly added owners can do right away.
While you’re at it, cover all the digital assets: the Google profile, the website, the domain name, the business phone numbers, and the social media accounts. They can be a meaningful part of the goodwill you are paying for.
Sellers: Fix Your Profile Before You Call a Broker
If you think you might sell in the next year or two, now is the time to look at your Google profile.
- Make sure your name, phone number, website, hours, and service areas are correct.
- Upload recent photos of your team and your work.
- Describe the services you offer.
- Respond professionally to reviews, good and bad.
- Most of all, build a routine for asking satisfied customers to leave honest reviews.
A little effort each week adds up. And a strong profile pays off even if you never sell. It helps customers find you, size you up, and feel confident calling you.
Buyers: A Great Rating Doesn’t Mean a Great Business
One last word of caution. A company can have a terrific Google reputation and still be a bad acquisition. The books may be unreliable. It may depend too heavily on the owner, have shrinking profits, or have serious employee problems.
The opposite is also true. A profitable manufacturer or commercial service company may have very few reviews because its customers come from long-term contracts, direct sales, or industry relationships. That doesn’t make it a bad business.
Google reviews are an important piece of the puzzle. They are not the whole puzzle. An experienced business broker can help you weigh a company’s online reputation alongside its financials, customer base, competitive position, and room to grow.
The Bottom Line
Whether you’re buying or selling in Sarasota, Bradenton, Venice, Lakewood Ranch, or anywhere else in Southwest Florida, don’t underestimate a company’s online presence.
For sellers, a well-kept Google profile helps prove the strength of your reputation and goodwill. For buyers, it is another window into customer satisfaction, how busy the business really is, how responsive management is, and where the marketing upside might be. For both, getting the profile properly transferred at closing protects an important part of what changes hands.
Sellers, build your Google reputation long before you plan to sell. Buyers, check that reputation before you commit.
The financial statements tell you what a company has earned. Its Google profile helps tell you what its customers think. Both deserve your attention.
Thinking About Selling Your Sarasota or Bradenton Business?
If you’re considering selling, work with someone who knows how to position your company for qualified buyers. Financial performance, customer relationships, online reputation, and goodwill all shape how buyers see your business and what they are willing to pay.
As a Sarasota Business Broker serving owners throughout Southwest Florida, I help sellers understand how marketable their companies are and guide them through every step of the sale. Whether you own a commercial lawn company, a manufacturer, a commercial cleaning business, an HVAC operation, or another profitable Florida company, I’d welcome the chance to talk about your exit plan.
Visit SteveVanLeeuwen.com to learn more about selling your business.
Steve Van Leeuwen is a business broker with Florida Business Opportunities, helping buyers and sellers of privately held businesses throughout Sarasota, Bradenton, and Southwest Florida.